Thought Leadership

Will My Project Benefit from Control Flow Concrete?

A new type of highly flowable concrete bridges the gap between conventional and self-consolidating concrete.

Conventional concrete has been used as a building material since Joseph Aspdin invented Portland cement in 1824. It works just fine for many building projects since it’s easy to produce and to deliver to the jobsite. However, it’s not exactly an easy material to work with. Concrete requires a tremendous amount of labor (and heavy equipment) just to move, place, and finish. With many general contractors struggling to find help in a tight job market, they would certainly benefit from a concrete solution that would reduce the amount of labor needed.Self-consolidating concrete came about, in part, to address this problem. It has high passing ability and it’s also self-leveling. This reduces the labor involved with pumping and placing of concrete. However, self-consolidating concrete is expensive to produce because it requires a specialized mix design with high powder contents and small coarse aggregates. And it doesn’t entirely solve the labor problem, because its sensitive mix requires extra quality control by the producer to minimize batch variability.A new concrete category, control flow concrete, recently emerged to bridge the gap between conventional and self-consolidating concrete. It offers many of the desirable characteristics of each type of concrete, without their respective negative aspect. Like self-consolidating concrete, control flow concrete flows and places easily, without negatively impacting stability or segregation resistance. It also can be placed with minimal vibration, which helps to cut costs. And as an added bonus, it doesn’t require extensive quality control to produce, so it eliminates some of the labor costs that come with self-consolidating concrete. Furthermore, control flow concrete is manufactured using conventional mix designs, with lower powder contents and larger coarse aggregates, further reducing material costs.

Choosing the right type of concrete for the job

Before selecting the type of concrete for your project, it’s important to understand the flow characteristics of each, as well as the placement requirements of the project.

Concrete type

Slump / Slump flow

Leveling characteristics

Water-to-cement ratio

GCP Admixtures used

Conventional concrete

6-8” slump

Requires vibration for consolidation

0.42

ADVA 198

Control flow concrete

16-25” slump flow

Requires minimal vibration for consolidation. Does not completely self level, so it can be placed even on small grades

0.42

ADVA 198 + CONCERA CP1028

or

CONCERA SA8080

Self-consolidating concrete

Greater than 25” slump flow

Self-leveling and consolidating

0.40

ADVA 405

Creating control flow concrete

Good slump flow retention is necessary for transportation and placement of concrete. Superplasticizers can be used to disperse the cement particles and reduce the yield stress of the concrete. However, high doses of traditional superplasticizers can cause segregation. Admixtures for control flow concrete produce segregation-resistant, high slump flow concretes with conventional mix designs. Using these admixtures allows for good slump flow, without having to use high doses of superplasticizers. This means that control flow concrete can be produced relatively inexpensively as compared to self-consolidating concrete.

Compressive strength

Control flow concrete has compressive strength that is equivalent to conventional concrete. The flow properties come from the chemistry of the admixture and not from water, so compressive strength is not negatively affected by the use of  admixtures for control flow concrete.

Static yield stress

Static yield stress is the measure of the force required to start motion in concrete at rest. This information is helpful because the less effort required to move the concrete, the lower the physical strain on staff and equipment at the job site. As expected, conventional concrete has the highest static yield stress, meaning it requires the most force to start this type of concrete moving. As shown in Figure 1, control flow concrete requires roughly two thirds less force to start control flow concrete moving. Self-consolidating concrete moves even more easily, requiring a small fraction of the force to start it moving from a resting state.

Bingham yield stress

Another important measurement is Bingham yield stress, which measures the effort required to stop concrete once it has been moving. It is useful to have concrete that will come to rest easily. Recent tests, shown in Figure 1, showed that it is easier to begin the flow of control flow concrete compared to conventional concrete, and that control flow concrete stops flowing more easily than self-consolidating concrete.

Figure 1:  Static and dynamic yield stress for conventional, control flow, and self-consolidating concrete.

Conclusion

Ultimately, control flow concrete shows considerable promise for reducing the tremendous physical effort—and associated labor costs—involved with using traditional concrete, without leaving concrete vulnerable to potential segregation. For many projects requiring highly flowable concrete, control flow concrete offers the best of both worlds: Concrete that’s easy to work with, but without high concrete production costs and quality control costs.

Concera admixtures for the production of control flow concrete are now available from GCP Applied Technologies. Find out more about this new technology at concera.gcpat.com or by talking to your local ready-mix producer.

About the authors:

Nathan Tregger is a principal scientist at GCP Applied Technologies Inc. (previously W.R. Grace), where he has been for the past 7 years.

Klaus-Alexander Rieder is a global R&D director for concrete products at GCP Applied Technologies.

Elizabeth Burns received her BS in chemistry from SMU in Dallas TX, and a PhD from Caltech, studying metathesis polymerization. She joined GCP Applied Technologies in 2016.

Joshua Curto joined the concrete admixtures group at GCP Applied Technologies in May of 2017.

Want to tweet about this article? Use hashtags #construction #technology #infrastructure #concrete #control #flow #building #labor

By |2018-07-24T19:14:54+00:007/24/2018|

Leave A Comment